Books, writers, and the business of publishingThe Saturday Letter

Section

Lists

Rankings, best-ofs and lists with the criteria shown.

A list is only worth reading if you can see how it was built, which is why every list in this section states what was eligible, what was excluded, and what rule was used to order it before the entries begin. A list that hides its method is just an assertion with numbering, and the arguments it starts are not worth having.

These are built to be disagreed with. The point of ranking anything is that the disagreements are where the thinking happens, and a list that nobody objects to has usually been assembled to avoid objection rather than to be right. Where a choice is genuinely contestable, the entry says so and gives the case against.

What you will not find here is a list generated from sales figures, prize shortlists or what other lists already contain. Those produce the same forty titles in a different order every time, which is why they are so easy to publish and so useless to read. Nor are there sponsored entries: nothing on any list in this section was placed, moved or added because somebody asked.

Lists are revised when they are wrong. Changes are noted rather than quietly made.

A wooden library card catalogue with rows of drawers
Photo: A wooden library card catalogue with rows of drawers. MarkBuckawicki, CC0.

In this section