Books, writers, and the business of publishingThe Saturday Letter

Section

Reviews

Reviews of new fiction and nonfiction, plus older books worth going back for, written on the assumption that you want to know whether to spend an evening on it.

Each review says what the book is doing, who it is for, where it falls short, and whether the weaknesses matter. A review that lists only strengths is a blurb, and a review that lists only faults is usually about the reviewer. The section covers literary fiction, crime, and nonfiction across history, memoir and the sciences, and treats genre books by the standards of their genre rather than complaining that a thriller is not a Henry James novel.

Spoilers are marked before they arrive, and avoided entirely for anything whose structure is the point.

No review here is paid for, and no publisher, author or publicist has ever been shown a review before publication or been able to change one afterwards. Receiving a review copy is not a promise to review a book, and where a book came to us free that makes no difference to what gets written about it.

Corrections matter more than reviews. If a date, an attribution or a publication year is wrong in anything here, tell us and it gets fixed with a note.

In this section

9 October 2026

Mystic River by Dennis Lehane

Lehane put his private detectives aside and wrote a crime novel where solving the murder barely matters. It is the book that made his name outside the genre.

9 October 2026

Piranesi by Susanna Clarke

A man lives alone in an endless house of statues and tides, and he is happy there. Almost anything else you could say about it is a spoiler.