Books, writers, and the business of publishingThe Saturday Letter

Essays

The Summer Harry Potter Stopped Being a Children's Book

The release of Goblet of Fire on 8 July 2000 proved the embargo, the midnight opening and the giant first printing worked, and publishing has used them ever since.

Window display at the Kohala Book Shop in Kapa'au, Hawaii
Window display at the Kohala Book Shop in Kapa'au, Hawaii. brewbooks from near Seattle, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0.

On 8 July 2000 a children’s fantasy novel went on sale in Britain and the United States at the same hour. It had been shipped on shrink wrapped pallets that shops weren’t allowed to open, and staff signed agreements saying so. People lined up at eleven at night for a hardback about a fourteen year old wizard.

None of that was normal then, and almost all of it is normal now. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire didn’t invent every one of those moves, but it proved they worked, and the trade has used them on memoirs and cookbooks ever since.

01What had already happened by 2000

The first book came out in Britain in June 1997 with a small print run, and in America in September 1998 under a new title, because Scholastic didn’t think American kids would pick up a book with “philosopher” on the cover. By the end of 1999 the first three books sat at the top of the New York Times bestseller list together and wouldn’t move.

In 2000 the Times created a separate children’s bestseller list. The official reason was that children’s books deserved their own coverage, but it also cleared three spots on the main list.

There was a big adult readership, it was a little embarrassed, and a publisher found a way to sell to it anyway.

Bloomsbury had also started printing the books with sober grown up covers, so commuters could read them on the train without advertising it.

Waiting for a midnight Harry Potter release
Waiting for a midnight Harry Potter release. Dtobias, CC BY-SA 3.0.

02How a one day book works

Scholastic’s first American printing was 3.8 million copies, which nobody had done before, and the bet was placed before a single copy sold. If the demand showed up, the print run looked smart. If it didn’t, several million hardbacks became a warehouse problem.

The embargo made the bet safer. With no reviews, extracts or serialization, the book became an event with a date, and people line up for events. Journalists wrote about the lines instead of the book, which was free advertising nobody could have bought.

Publishers took away the idea that keeping information scarce sells as well as keeping stock scarce, and they have been misusing it ever since. An embargo on a book nobody is waiting for just means nobody writes about it until it’s too late. Potter worked because three earlier books had built an audience that was already impatient.

03The two arguments that summer

Some serious critics looked at the prose, found it ordinary and said so. They weren’t wrong about the sentences, but they were answering a question nobody asked. The draw was the structure, a school year as the plot, a mystery in each book, a growing cast with a long memory, and a willingness to let kids be scared.

Platform 9 3/4 at King's Cross, London
Platform 9 3/4 at King's Cross, London. Bert Seghers, CC0.

The other fight was about witchcraft. Around the turn of the century the series was the most challenged set of books in American libraries for three years running. The challenges mostly failed, and they sold a lot of copies along the way.

04Bigger every time

Goblet of Fire ran to 734 pages in the American first edition, about twice the length of the first book. Order of the Phoenix in 2003 was longer still. Children’s publishing had treated length as a hard limit, and these books showed kids would happily read eight hundred pages if they cared about what happened.

The launches kept growing too. When Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows came out in July 2007, Scholastic reported 8.3 million copies sold in the United States in the first twenty four hours. The machinery tested in 2000 had become the standard for any book with a fan base.

05What it changed

Warner Bros. had bought the film rights the year before, and the first film arrived in November 2001. After that it was an entertainment property with books attached. Summer 2000 is the short gap between those two things, which is what makes it the interesting moment.

  • Children’s and young adult books became a serious commercial category, with budgets and advances to match.
  • Long books stopped being off limits for young readers.
  • The industry picked up a lasting and mostly expensive habit of hunting for the next one.

What that week didn’t prove is that any of it can be repeated on purpose. A quarter century of trying is pretty good evidence on that.

Duncan McAdams runs Book Magazine. Corrections and pitches go through the contact page, and corrections get read first.

The Saturday Letter

One book worth your week, every Saturday