What a Literary Biography Is For
Reading a writer’s life to explain their books rarely works. Biography is still worth reading, but for a different reason than the jacket copy gives.

The obvious objection to literary biography has never really been answered. The books are what a writer chose to make public, and the life is the part they didn’t. Reading one to explain the other assumes a connection most writers spent their careers denying.
The form keeps selling anyway, and now and then it produces something better than anything its subject wrote. So it is worth asking what it actually does.
01Three things a biography can be
The first is a record. Somebody has to establish where a person was in March 1923, what they were paid, who they wrote to and what they crossed out. Richard Ellmann’s life of Joyce and Leon Edel’s five volumes on Henry James are records of this kind, so complete that for decades nobody needed to go back to the papers.

The second is an argument. Lytton Strachey’s Eminent Victorians in 1918 did more damage to the respectful Victorian biography than any critic, by being short, selective and openly skeptical of its subjects. It showed a life could be written as a case instead of a chronicle.
The third and rarest is a book about why the first two are so hard. Janet Malcolm’s The Silent Woman in 1994 set out to write about Sylvia Plath and ended up writing about the biographers, the estate and her own place among them.
All three go back to James Boswell’s Life of Samuel Johnson in 1791, which is still the book people mean when they say a biography can be literature. Boswell had something later biographers rarely get, which is years of notes on what his subject actually said at dinner.
02The permission problem
Biography is the only major form that needs somebody's permission to be done properly.
Copyright in a writer’s unpublished letters and diaries belongs to the writer, and after death to the estate. A biographer can read a letter in an archive and describe it, but can quote almost none of it without permission. In 1987 Ian Hamilton’s biography of J. D. Salinger was effectively stopped by a court that found his use of the unpublished letters wasn’t fair use, and the book had to be rewritten into something else.
So there is a market in cooperation. An estate that grants access gets a biographer in its debt, and an estate that refuses gets either silence or a hostile book written from outside. That is why the authorized life is the one to read with more caution, not less. It has better material and more careful conclusions. The unauthorized one has worse material and no reason to be kind.
03Long lives and short ones
The multi volume life can take decades and outlast its subject’s reputation. Robert Caro has given most of a working life to Lyndon Johnson, after writing The Power Broker about Robert Moses. When it works it is the most impressive thing in nonfiction, but when it doesn’t you get four volumes about a minor poet.
A good short biography is criticism disguised as a story, since everything left out is a choice about what mattered. A bad one is an encyclopedia entry with a hardback price.
Hermione Lee’s Virginia Woolf in 1996 is a good example of the middle path. It is long, but it is organized by themes instead of marching through every year, and it is open about the problem of writing a life of somebody who wrote so much about her own.
04What it is actually good for
It isn’t good at explaining the books. Finding the author’s mother in a character and calling it settled is the weakest thing the form does. What biography is good at is the conditions. How much a writer was paid, what they read the year before the good book, which editor changed the structure, how many attempts failed first and what was going on in the house while they worked.
The best literary biographies are books about work. They get more interesting the more seriously they treat writing as a job done on particular days under particular pressures, and more tedious the more they want the life to be a key.
Duncan McAdams runs Book Magazine. Corrections and pitches go through the contact page, and corrections get read first.
The Saturday Letter


