When Books Become Movies and Why the Book Wins
Hollywood has been buying novels since the silent era. Here is how the deal works, why the book usually comes off better, and what streaming changed.

Some of the biggest films ever made started as books. Gone with the Wind was a bestselling novel before it was a 1939 film, and The Godfather, Jaws and Life of Pi all started on paper. For publishers and authors, a film deal can change a book’s life, even when the film is bad.
01How the deal works
Most books are never filmed, but a lot of them get optioned. An option is a payment for the exclusive right to try to make a film for a set period, often a year or eighteen months. If the film gets made, the producer pays a much bigger purchase price. If it doesn’t, the rights go back to the author, who keeps the option money.

That is why so many authors have sold film rights without ever seeing a film. The option is the common part, and the movie is the rare one.
The option is the common part, and the movie is the rare one.
02Why the book usually wins
A novel can stay inside a character’s head for four hundred pages, and a film has two hours and mostly has to show things from the outside. The parts that make a book great are often the hardest to film. Mystic River is a good example. The 2003 film is faithful and well acted, but it can’t give you the twenty five years of ordinary life the novel spends between the crime and the murder.
Sometimes the film is better. Jaws and The Godfather are usually named here, and the novelists themselves had a hand in both screenplays.
Some writers move into the film business themselves. Dennis Lehane wrote for television, and Gillian Flynn wrote the screenplay for the film of her own novel Gone Girl in 2014. When the author writes the script, the film tends to keep more of what made the book work.
03The tie in edition
A film sells books, often more than the book ever sold on its own. Publishers reissue the novel with the movie poster on the cover and put it at the front of the store. Plenty of readers buy the tie in edition, read it after the film, and decide the book was better anyway.
04What streaming changed
Long running crime and fantasy series used to be hard to fit into films. Streaming made them easier to adapt, because a season of television has eight or ten hours to work with. Reacher, based on Lee Child’s Jack Reacher novels, started on Prime Video in 2022, and many book series now go straight to television instead of the cinema.
That has been good for long novels and series that never fit into two hours. It has also made the option market busier than ever, which means more authors getting paid for films that never get made.
Duncan McAdams runs Book Magazine. Corrections and pitches go through the contact page, and corrections get read first.
The Saturday Letter


