Why Romance Outsells Almost Every Other Genre
Romance has been the biggest part of the paperback business for decades. It has changed shape every few years and kept its readers the whole time.

A romance novel has two requirements. The love story has to be the main plot, and the ending has to leave the reader satisfied and hopeful. That is the definition the Romance Writers of America has used, and everything else is open. A romance can be set in Regency London, a Texas small town, outer space or a dragon academy.
01Who reads it and how much
Romance has been the engine of the paperback business for a long time. In 1991 romances made up 46 percent of the mass market paperbacks sold in the United States. In 2008 romance fiction brought in $1.37 billion, about 13.5 percent of the consumer book market, from more than 7,000 new titles. More than 74 million Americans said they read at least one romance that year.
Most romance buyers are women, but not all. A 2008 study for the Romance Writers of America put men at 16 percent of buyers, and a 2017 study put them at 18 percent. Romance readers also read a lot, which is why the genre moved so quickly to ebooks and cheap downloads when those arrived.
It is still growing. Publishers Weekly reported that romance print sales rose almost 9 percent in 2024, using Circana BookScan figures. Through September 2024, seven of the ten bestselling print books of the year were romance or romantasy.

02The main subgenres
- Category romance. Short novels published in numbered lines every month, the Harlequin model. Harlequin began distributing in North America in 1957 and bought Mills & Boon in 1971.
- Historical. Regency England is the most famous setting, but the shelf runs from Scottish clans to the American West. Diana Gabaldon‘s Outlander (1991) mixes it with time travel.
- Contemporary. Present day settings, from small town stories to the novels of Emily Henry and Colleen Hoover.
- Romantic suspense and paranormal. A love story with a crime, a ghost or a vampire attached, like Charlaine Harris‘s Sookie Stackhouse books.
- Inspirational. Romances with a faith element and no explicit scenes.
In 2006 category romance was about 40 percent of the US romance market, historical 17 percent and contemporary 16 percent.
03Chick lit and the years around 2000
Helen Fielding’s Bridget Jones’s Diary came out in 1996, a loose modern take on Jane Austen‘s Pride and Prejudice, and it became the model for a whole category. Candace Bushnell’s Sex and the City followed in 1997. Chick lit books were funny, written in the first person, and about a single woman’s job, friends and love life, and for a few years they topped bestseller lists.
Sophie Kinsella was the biggest name of that wave. The Secret Dreamworld of a Shopaholic, published in America as Confessions of a Shopaholic, came out in 2000 and grew into a series of ten titles. Her books sold more than 50 million copies in more than 60 countries. She later called her work romantic comedy rather than chick lit, and she died in December 2025 at 55.
Publishers launched whole imprints for chick lit in the early 2000s. By the early 2010s most had dropped the label, though the books themselves never really went away. A lot of what gets called rom com now would have been shelved as chick lit in 2003.
04Two names on one cover
Romance has more writing teams than most genres. Christina Lauren is the pen name of Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings, who met in 2009 writing fan fiction online and began writing together in 2010. Their books include Beautiful Bastard (2013) and The Unhoneymooners (2019). Ilona Andrews is the pen name of Ilona and Andrew Gordon, who write the Kate Daniels books, starting with Magic Bites in 2007, and the Hidden Legacy series.
05Romantasy and BookTok
The biggest change of the 2020s is romantasy, fantasy novels where the love story carries the plot. Sarah J. Maas started Throne of Glass at 16 and posted it online before it was published in 2012. A Court of Thorns and Roses followed in 2015, and her books had sold more than 75 million copies by 2024. Rebecca Yarros published Fourth Wing in 2023, and it spent 65 weeks on the New York Times list by August 2024. Onyx Storm, the third Empyrean book, sold more than 2.7 million copies in its first week.
Romance readers find books through each other, and the internet just made that louder.
Much of this was pushed along by BookTok, the reading community on TikTok. Colleen Hoover’s It Ends with Us came out in 2016 and found a second, much larger audience there years later. In 2024 alone, It Ends with Us and its sequel sold more than 1.6 million print copies combined. Emily Henry took a quieter route, from young adult novels starting in 2016 to Beach Read in 2020, and now a new Emily Henry book is one of the dependable events of a publishing year.
A wrong name, title or year in Why Romance Outsells Almost Every Other Genre can be reported through the contact page, where corrections get read first.
Sources: Wikipedia and Publishers Weekly
Where the facts in Why Romance Outsells Almost Every Other Genre come from
- Romance novel, Wikipedia
- Print book sales saw a small sales increase in 2024, Publishers Weekly
- Riding on romance and romantasy print book sales edge into positive territory, Publishers Weekly
- Chick lit, Wikipedia
- Bridget Jones's Diary, Wikipedia
- Sophie Kinsella, Wikipedia
- Christina Lauren, Wikipedia
- Ilona Andrews, Wikipedia
- Romantasy, Wikipedia
- Sarah J. Maas, Wikipedia
- Rebecca Yarros, Wikipedia
- Colleen Hoover, Wikipedia
- Emily Henry, Wikipedia
Questions and answers
What makes a book a romance novel?
By the Romance Writers of America definition, a romance novel needs the love story as its main plot and an ending that leaves readers satisfied and hopeful. The setting can be anything, from Regency London to a dragon academy.
How big is the romance genre?
Romance made up 46 percent of American mass market paperback sales in 1991. In 2008 romance fiction earned $1.37 billion, about 13.5 percent of the consumer book market, and more than 74 million Americans read at least one romance.
What is romantasy?
Romantasy is fantasy where the love story drives the plot, the biggest romance trend of the 2020s. Sarah J. Maas and Rebecca Yarros lead it, and Yarros's Onyx Storm sold more than 2.7 million copies in its first week.
Who is the author Christina Lauren?
Christina Lauren is the romance pen name of Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings, who met writing fan fiction online in 2009 and began writing together in 2010. Their romance novels include Beautiful Bastard and The Unhoneymooners.
The Saturday Letter


