Books, writers, and the business of publishingThe Saturday Letter

Essays

How to Start a Book Club and Keep It Going

Most book clubs fall apart over the calendar and the reading list, not the books. A few simple habits keep one running for years.

Powell's City of Books, Portland
Powell's City of Books, Portland. Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Book clubs are less common than they look on social media. In a Pew Research Center survey of American adults taken in October 2025, 7 percent said they had taken part in a book club in the past year, 10 percent of women and 5 percent of men. The ones that last tend to share a few things. They are small, they meet on a fixed schedule, and somebody is in charge of keeping it going.

01Getting the size and schedule right

Six to twelve members is a good range. With fewer than six, one or two people missing a month leaves a conversation between three people. With more than twelve, the quiet members stop talking and the group splits into side conversations. Invite a few more people than you want, since somebody always drops out after the first couple of months.

Pick a regular slot, like the second Tuesday of every month, and stick to it. A club that schedules each meeting by group text will spend more time on dates than on books. Monthly is the usual pace. It gives people with jobs and kids time to finish a novel of normal length.

  • Set a start and end time. Two hours is plenty, with the first half hour for food and catching up.
  • Rotate the host. Whoever hosts usually picks the book, which spreads the work and keeps the list varied.
  • Keep food simple. Snacks or potluck. If hosting turns into a dinner party, people start skipping their turn.
  • Decide what happens if someone hasn’t finished. Most clubs welcome them anyway and talk about the ending openly.

02Picking books

The best book club books give people something to disagree about. A character who makes a choice half the room would never make, a family secret, or an ending that can be read two ways will carry a whole evening. A book everyone simply liked often runs out of conversation in twenty minutes.

That is why certain authors show up on book club lists again and again. Jodi Picoult builds novels like My Sister’s Keeper and Nineteen Minutes around moral questions with no easy answer. Celeste Ng‘s Little Fires Everywhere splits readers over who is in the right. Kristin Hannah‘s The Nightingale and The Four Winds give a group history and family drama at once. Liane Moriarty, Ann Patchett and Fredrik Backman are also safe bets.

A book everyone liked can run out of conversation in twenty minutes.

Keep length in mind. A 700 page novel in a month will lose half the group. Check that the book is easy to get in paperback, at the library or as an ebook, and mix in an older book or a nonfiction title now and then so the list doesn’t turn into the same kind of novel every month.

03Running the discussion

Someone should lead each meeting, usually the person who picked the book. That person doesn’t need to lecture. The job is to have four or five questions ready, start with an easy one, and draw in the people who haven’t said anything yet.

Reading group guides help. Publishers put out free discussion guides for many novels, and Penguin Random House alone lists hundreds of them. Some paperbacks print a guide in the back, with discussion questions, an author interview or a short biography. Use the questions as a starting point, not a script. If the group goes off on a tangent about a character, that is usually the best part of the night.

Reading space at Deichman Bjørvika, Oslo
Reading space at Deichman Bjørvika, Oslo. Åshild Telle, CC BY-SA 4.0.

04Library kits and online clubs

Buying a new hardcover every month adds up, and this is where libraries come in. Many public libraries lend book club kits, a bag with enough copies of one title for a whole group. At Hennepin County Library in Minnesota a kit holds 8 to 10 copies and can be kept for six weeks, with one member responsible for all of them. The Lake Agassiz Regional Library kits hold 10 copies plus a discussion guide and hosting tips, also for six weeks. Ask at your own library, since kits are usually reserved well ahead.

Online clubs solve the scheduling problem for friends who live in different places. A video call works fine for a small group, though it helps to keep it shorter than an in person meeting and to have the leader call on people so everyone isn’t talking at once. Some clubs mix the two, meeting in person most months and online when the weather or the calendar gets in the way.

The clubs that survive for years are the ones where people look forward to the evening whether or not they loved the book. Keep the schedule steady, keep the list varied, and let the conversation wander.

A wrong name, title or year in How to Start a Book Club and Keep It Going can be reported through the contact page, where corrections get read first.

Sources: Pew Research Center, Penguin Random House, Hennepin County Library and Lake Agassiz Regional Library

Where the facts in How to Start a Book Club and Keep It Going come from

Questions and answers

How do you start a book club?

To start a book club, invite a few more people than you need so you land at six to twelve members, set a fixed monthly slot such as the second Tuesday, rotate the host and keep the food simple.

How many people should be in a book club?

Six to twelve members suits a book club. Below six, a couple of absences shrink the talk to three people, and above twelve the quieter members fall silent while the group breaks into side conversations.

What are good books for a book club?

Good book club picks give members something to argue over, like a divisive choice, a family secret or an ambiguous ending. Jodi Picoult, Celeste Ng's Little Fires Everywhere and Kristin Hannah's The Nightingale are frequent choices, and very long novels lose half the group.

Do libraries lend book club kits?

Many public libraries lend book club kits holding multiple copies of one title. Hennepin County Library kits contain 8 to 10 copies for six weeks, and Lake Agassiz Regional Library kits include 10 copies plus a discussion guide. Reserve early.

The Saturday Letter

One book worth your week, every Saturday