Books, writers, and the business of publishingThe Saturday Letter

Essays

How a First Novel Gets Noticed

Most debut novels come out quietly and disappear just as quietly. The ones that break through usually had help from an agent, a publisher willing to bet, a prize or a book club.

Shelves inside the Strand Bookstore in New York
Shelves inside the Strand Bookstore in New York. DocteurCosmos, CC BY 4.0.

A first novel has nothing going for it except the book. There is no earlier title for readers to remember, no sales record for stores to look at, and no fans waiting for the next one. Almost everything that gets a debut noticed is some way of solving that problem.

01It usually starts with an agent

Most big publishers don’t read manuscripts sent in cold, so a novelist’s first job is usually finding a literary agent. The agent sends the book to editors, and when more than one wants it, the agent runs an auction. A bigger advance matters beyond the money, because a publisher that pays a lot has every reason to push the book hard.

Agents find writers in odd ways. Sally Rooney published an essay in The Dublin Review in 2015 that caught the eye of Tracy Bohan at the Wylie Agency. Bohan got in touch, Rooney later sent her a manuscript, and seven publishers bid on it. Conversations with Friends came out from Faber in 2017, and her second novel, Normal People, was longlisted for the Man Booker Prize the next year and became a BBC and Hulu series in 2020. Zadie Smith was still a student at Cambridge when her short stories in a student anthology drew a publisher’s interest. White Teeth went to auction in 1997 on a partial manuscript, before she had finished writing it.

02The first print run is a signal

When a publisher believes in a debut, it prints a lot of copies, and bookstores notice. Knopf printed 75,000 copies of Donna Tartt‘s The Secret History in 1992, when about 10,000 was usual for a first novel. A big first printing means stacks in more shops and a front table instead of a single copy spine out on a shelf, and that alone puts the book in more hands. Knopf also gave it a cover by Chip Kidd and Barbara de Wilde that people still recognize, which is another way a publisher shows it means business.

A debut has nothing going for it except the book, so everything around it has to do the work.

Powell's City of Books, Portland
Powell's City of Books, Portland. Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0.

03Prizes just for first books

Some prizes are only for debuts, and winning one can turn a quiet book into a known one.

  • The PEN/Hemingway Award. Founded in 1976 by Mary Welsh Hemingway for an American writer’s first novel or story collection. It pays $25,000, and winners include Tommy Orange for There There in 2019.
  • The Center for Fiction First Novel Prize. Given since 2006 under a few different names, with $10,000 to the winner and $1,000 to each finalist. Marisha Pessl won the first one for Special Topics in Calamity Physics. Junot Díaz won in 2007 for The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, and Viet Thanh Nguyen won in 2015 for The Sympathizer.
  • British first book prizes. White Teeth won the Whitbread first novel award, the Guardian First Book Award and the James Tait Black prize for fiction.

A shortlist can be nearly as useful as a win. It puts the book in front of booksellers and reviewers who might never have opened it, at exactly the moment the publisher needs a reason to reorder.

04Book clubs and word of mouth

Some debuts are carried more by readers than by critics. Alice Sebold’s The Lovely Bones came out from Little, Brown in 2002 and became an instant bestseller. Peter Jackson’s film followed in 2009.

Delia Owens was a zoologist before she was a novelist. Where the Crawdads Sing came out from Putnam in August 2018, and Reese Witherspoon picked it for her book club the next month. It had sold more than 4.5 million copies by the end of 2019 and 18 million by April 2023, and the film came out in 2022. A celebrity pick can do for a debut what months of reviews can’t.

Celeste Ng shows the slower path. Everything I Never Told You came out in 2014 and was named Amazon’s book of the year and a New York Times Notable Book. That built an audience for her second novel, Little Fires Everywhere, which became a Hulu series in 2020.

None of this is a formula. Plenty of books with big advances sink, and plenty of small debuts find readers years later through a paperback, a teacher or a friend who won’t stop talking about it. But nearly every famous first novel had at least one of these things working for it, and most had several.

A wrong name, title or year in How a First Novel Gets Noticed can be reported through the contact page, where corrections get read first.

Questions and answers

How do debut novels get noticed?

A first novel usually gets noticed through some mix of a literary agent who runs an auction, a publisher that pays a big advance and prints heavily, a prize for debuts, or a book club pick that spreads word of mouth.

How did Sally Rooney find her agent?

Sally Rooney's 2015 essay in The Dublin Review caught the attention of agent Tracy Bohan at the Wylie Agency. Seven publishers then bid on Rooney's manuscript, and her first novel, Conversations with Friends, came out from Faber in 2017.

How many copies of The Secret History were printed?

Knopf printed 75,000 copies of Donna Tartt's first novel The Secret History in 1992, when around 10,000 was typical for a debut. The large run, plus a Chip Kidd and Barbara de Wilde cover, signaled the publisher's commitment.

What prizes are there for first novels?

Prizes for first novels include the PEN/Hemingway Award, founded in 1976 and paying $25,000, and the Center for Fiction First Novel Prize, given since 2006 with $10,000 to the winner. Even a debut prize shortlist can prompt bookstore reorders.

The Saturday Letter

One book worth your week, every Saturday